On January 4, 2016, the B. F. Skinner Foundation launched a new project – Skinner’s Quote of the Day. Quotes from B. F. Skinner’s works, selected by renowned scientists, appear daily Monday-Friday in order, starting with Chapter 1 of each book and running all the way through the last chapter. We started with the Science and Human Behavior (January-December 2916), followed by About Behaviorism (January-November 2017), Contingencies of Reinforcement (January-October 2018), Recent Issues (October 2018-May 2019), Reflections on Behaviorism and Society (May 2019-February 2020), and now moving on to Upon Further Reflection (from February 10 2020).
You can leave your comments here (registered users only), or join the discussion on our open Facebook forum. Please keep your comments brief and directly related to the quote.
… in turning to probability of response or, more immediately, to frequency of responding we find a datum which behaves in an orderly fashion under a great variety of conditions.…
. . . under experimental conditions, a specific response can be reinforced by the production or clarification of a stimulus which controls other behavior. The matter is of considerable practical…
Unfortunately mere “attending” (as in reading a book or listening to a concert) has dimensions which are difficult to study. But behavior with comparable effects is sometimes accessible, such as…
We often forget that looking at a visual pattern or listening to a sound is itself behavior, because we are likely to be impressed by the more important behavior which…
In watching experiments of the sort described above, most people feel that they could “figure out” a schedule of reinforcement and adjust to it more efficiently than the experimental organism.…
What about man? Is rate of responding still an orderly and meaningful datum here, or is human behavior the exception in which spontaneity and and caprice still reign? (p. 157)
In one of Olds’ experiments, a rat presses a lever to give itself mild electrical stimulation in the anterior hypothalamus. When every response is so “reinforced,” behavior is sustained in…
Much of what we do during the day is done not because of the positive reinforcements we receive but because of aversive consequences we avoid. The whole field of escape,…
Typical curves [of dark-adaptation in the pigeon] show a break as the dark-adaptation process shifts from the cone elements in the retina to the rods. (p. 146)
The control of behavior achieved with methods based upon rate of responding has given rise to a new psychophysics of lower organisms. It appears to be possible to learn as…
The general rule seems to be that the stimuli present at the moment of reinforcement produce a maximal probability that the response will be repeated. Any change in the stimulating…
In speaking about colors projected on the key or the fact that a key is on the right or left, we are, of course, talking about stimuli. Moreover, they are…
In our study of different kinds of schedules of reinforcement, Ferster and I found that it was possible to set up several performances in a single pigeon by bringing each…
By differentially reinforcing high rates of responding, pigeons have been made to respond as rapidly as 10 to 15 responses per second. Here technical problems become crucial . . .…
In Schedules of Reinforcement Charles B. Ferster and I checked this explanation [in terms of conditions at the moment of reinforcement] of the effect of schedules by controlling conditions more…
Interval and ratio schedules have different effects for several reasons. When a reinforcement is scheduled by a timer, the probability of reinforcement increases during any pause, and the first responses…
After certain schedules, the rate may decline in a smoothly accelerated extinction curve. After other schedules, when the rate itself enters prominently into the experimental conditions, it may oscillate widely.…
A variable-ratio schedule programmed by a counter corresponds to the variable interval schedule programmed by a timer. Reinforcement is contingent on a given average number of responses but the numbers…
Anyone who has seen workers paid on such a schedule is familiar with some features of the performance generated: a high rate is sustained for long periods of time. For…
Reinforcements may be scheduled with a counter instead of a timer. For example, we may maintain a fixed ratio between responses and reinforcements. In industry this schedule is referred to…
If the length of interval is varied essentially at random [on a “variable-interval” schedule], responding occurs at a single rate represented by a constant slope in the cumulative record. (p.…
The over-all pattern of performance on a “fixed-interval” schedule is a fairly smoothly accelerating scallop in each interval, the acceleration being more rapid the longer the initial pause. Local effects…
More interesting phenomena are generated when responses are merely intermittently reinforced. It is characteristic of everyday life that few of the things we do always “pay off.” (p. 135)
A single presentation of food, following immediately upon a response, increases the rate with which responses to the key are subsequently emitted so long as the pigeon remains hungry. (p.…
Any consequence of behavior which is rewarding or, more technically, reinforcing increases the probability of further responding. Unfortunately, a consequence which is punishing has a much more complex result. (p.…
Among the conditions which alter rate of responding are some of the consequences of behavior. Operant behavior usually affects the environment and generates stimuli which “feed back” to the organism.…
Probability of responding is a difficult datum. We may avoid controversial issues by turning at once to a practical measure, the frequency with which a response is emitted. (p. 134)
In studying such [operant] behavior we must make certain preliminary decisions. We begin by choosing an organism—one which we hope will be representative but which is first merely convenient. We…
The behavior through which the individual deals with the surrounding environment and gets from it the things it needs for its existence and for the propagation of the species cannot…
Not so long ago the expression “a science of behavior” would have been regarded as a contradiction in terms. Living organisms were distinguished by the fact that they were spontaneous…
The organism whose behavior is most extensively modified and most completely controlled in research of the sort I have described is the experimenter himself. (p. 129)
When behavior shows order and consistency, we are much less likely to be concerned with physiological or mentalistic causes. A datum emerges which takes the place of theoretical fantasy. (p.…
When we have achieved a practical control over the organism, theories of behavior loose their point. (p. 127)
We are within reach of a science of the individual. This will be achieved, not by resorting to some special theory of knowledge in which intuition or understanding takes the…
There is perhaps no field in which behavior is customarily described more indirectly than psychiatry. (p. 125)
In choosing rate of responding as a basic datum and in recording this conveniently in a cumulative curve, we make important temporal aspects of behavior visible. Once this has happened,…
When you have the responsibility of making absolutely sure that a given organism will engage in a given sort of behavior at a given time, you quickly grow impatient with…
If I engaged in Experimental Design at all, it was simply to complete or extend some evidence of order already observed. (p. 119)
Of course, I was working on a basic Assumption—that there was order in behavior if I could only discover it—but such an assumption is not to be confused with the…
I never faced a Problem which was more than the eternal problem of finding order. I never attacked a problem by constructing a Hypothesis. I never deduced Theorems or submitted…
Since I do not wish to deprecate the hypothetico-deductive method, I am glad to testify to its usefulness. It led me to apply our second principle of unformalized scientific method…
I can easily recall the excitement of that first complete extinction curve. . . I had made contact with Pavlov at last! Here was a curve uncorrupted by the physiological…
Now, as soon as you begin to complicate an apparatus, you necessarily invoke a fourth principle of scientific practice: Apparatuses sometimes break down. I had only to wait for the…
Psychologists have adopted cumulative curves only very slowly, but I think it is fair to say that they have become an indispensable tool for certain purposes of analysis. (p. 116)
A third unformalized principle of scientific practice: Some people are lucky. (p. 115)
... a second unformalized principle of scientific practice: Some ways of doing research are easier than others. I got tired of carrying the rat back to the other end of…
... a first principle not formally recognized by scientific methodologists: When you run into something interesting, drop everything else and study it. (p. 112)
I had the clue from Pavlov: Control your conditions and you will see order.
So far as I can see, I began simply by looking for lawful processes in the behavior of the intact organism. Pavlov had shown the way; but I could not…
It had been said of Loeb, and might have been said of Crozier, that he “resented the nervous system.” Whether this was true or not, the fact was that both…